Here’s a creamy, cold cocktail that’s exceedingly delicious in any season: Bourbon Milk Punch! You might not expect it, but the combination of milk and bourbon is spot on. The richness of the milk perfectly compliments the oak and vanilla notes in the bourbon. Add a vanilla and nutmeg, and this historic cocktail is every bit as epic today as the day it was invented! It always surprises us at how well this flavor combination works. More milk punch, please!
Ingredients in bourbon milk punch
Milk punch is a drink made with brandy or bourbon, milk, sugar, and vanilla extract. This drink recipe was first recorded 1688 in Scotland! How’s that for history? The first mention in a cookbook was in 1711, and Benjamin Franklin recorded a version of it in 1763. It’s served in New Orleans for brunch, and also popular around the holidays. Our classic Milk Punch has both brandy and bourbon. This recipe skips the bourbon and it’s just as delicious, in our book! The ingredients you’ll need for bourbon milk punch are:
Whole milkBourbon whiskeySimple syrupVanillaGrated nutmeg, for the garnish
Whole milk vs 2%
Can you substitute 2% milk in a bourbon milk punch? Yes! Just keep in mind that the drink won’t be nearly as rich as creamy. But if you’re looking to cut some calories, it does work! It’s nearly as tasty as the original.
How to make bourbon milk punch (basic steps)
While punch might make you think of a big punch bowl, this is a typical shaken cocktail. Just shake it up and strain the drink into a glass! Here’s what to do:
Bourbon milk punch for a crowd: in a pitcher
Making bourbon milk punch for entertaining? You can make it in a pitcher! Simply stir together the following in a pitcher to make 8 servings:
2 ½ cups whole milk2 cups bourbon whiskey½ cup simple syrup1 ½ tablespoons vanilla extract
When you’re ready to serve, pour the mixture over ice (this is important to get the dilution that shaking with ice would achieve). Garnish in the same way as the recipe below!
More bourbon cocktails
When it comes to cocktails, there are so many bourbon drinks to try! Here are some of our favorites:
Try the classic, Best Bourbon Sour or two-toned New York SourGo for a BoulevardierTry a John Collins or Bourbon SazeracGrab a Cranberry Bourbon Cocktail, Apple Cider Hot Toddy or Bourbon Hot ToddyTry a Maple Bourbon SmashOpt for a Bourbon Manhattan or Classic Old Fashioned
5 from 2 reviews
