Paneer Tikka Masala Restaurant Style

Craving vegetarian Indian takeout? Making this paneer tikka masala recipe is your answer. This is an easy homemade recipe that rivals any Indian restaurant out there. It takes minutes to make, and you can even marinate the paneer cheese in advance!

Why this recipe works

If you’ve ever ordered this dish at a restaurant, you may be apprehensive to make it at home, but honestly, it’s a mostly hands-off recipe that even a beginner cook could make.

Full of flavor. Made with aromatic tikka masala curry paste, this dish turns out delicious and super flavorful every single time. Perfect texture. Unlike other curries or stews that rely on specific cooking times to ensure the protein is moist and tender, this recipe is super forgiving, and the paneer remains tender and soft at all times. 100% Vegetarian. This is the perfect Indian curry to make when you need a meat-free meal that packs in protein.

Ingredients needed

This paneer masala tikka recipe is so simple, and besides the paneer and a bunch of fragrant spices, there isn’t really much else needed to make. Here is what you’ll need:

Paneer. Thanks to the global cooking trend, paneer is easily found at almost any mainstream grocery store, usually in the cheese section (mine was near the feta cheese). Cut into 2-inch pieces. Yogurt. Plain Greek yogurt to marinate the paneer. Greek yogurt or plain coconut yogurt also works. Tikka masala curry paste. A flavorful paste that contains a range of spices and tomato paste. While you can make your own, I find the store bought kind to be a simple shortcut that doesn’t affect the flavor whatsoever. Curry leaves. To give the dish a robust curry flavor. Onion. Chopped. Chili pepper. Chopped and seeded. Adjust the number of chilis you use depending on the level of spiciness you like. I like mine more on the spicier side so tend to add more but if it’s your first time, be conservative (you can always add more!). Garlic. Minced. Vegetable broth. To provide a flavorful base for the sauce. Choose a good quality broth with minimal additives in it. Tomatoes. Canned diced tomatoes or fresh ones. Tomato paste. To enrich the flavor of the sauce. Heavy cream. To make the tikka masala sauce silky smooth. Either standard heavy cream or heavy whipping cream will work. Lemon juice. To balance and brighten the flavor of the dish. Olive oil. To sauté the vegetables and pan-fry the paneer. Any other neutral cooking oil will work.

How to make paneer tikka masala

Marinate the paneer: Add yogurt and half the tikka masala curry to a large mixing bowl. Slice the paneer cheese into same-size pieces and add to the bowl. Mix to coat the cheese with yogurt, then cover the bowl and refrigerate for at least 10 minutes or up to 4 hours. Want to make this dish dairy-free? Swap out the heavy cream for full-fat coconut cream. Make the gravy: Heat oil in a non-stick pan. Once hot, add the curry leaves and cook for a few minutes until fragrant. Add the chopped onion, chili peppers, and minced garlic. Cook for a couple of minutes until translucent. Add the remaining tikka masala curry paste along with the vegetable broth, tomatoes, and tomato paste. Reduce the heat to low and allow the sauce to simmer until it thickens into a rich gravy. Pan-fry paneer and combine it with the gravy: While the sauce cooks, add oil to a pan and pan-fry the paneer until it’s nice and golden. Add the paneer to the sauce and cook for another 15 minutes. Add the heavy cream and lemon juice and serve immediately.

Tips to make the best recipe

Soak the paneer in hot water. It is common for store-bought paneer to be a little hard or rubbery. If this is the case for you, slice the cheese and soak it in hot water for around 10 minutes. The hot water will greatly improve the consistency of the cheese. Strain the gravy to make it extra smooth. While this step is totally optional, you can strain the sauce to make it extra smooth. Add butter to make it creamier. Once you add the heavy cream, add a knob of butter to the sauce to make it rich, creamy, and glossy. Top with fresh herbs. Fresh cilantro and mint are the perfect finishing touch to this dish.

Storage instructions

To store. Place leftovers in an airtight container in the fridge. It will last 3 to 5 days in the refrigerator. To reheat. Reheat paneer tikka masala on the stove on low heat. Add water, vegetable broth, or heavy cream if needed.