Here’s a fun treat for the season: try this pumpkin pudding! The sweet custard is made like a traditional homemade pudding, with added pumpkin puree and cozy spices. To serve, add crushed gingersnaps or graham crackers and top with whipped cream! It’s like pumpkin pie filling in a glass: but a mini version with all the fun and none of the fuss. Here’s how to make it!
What you need for this pumpkin pudding recipe
Have you ever made a homemade pudding, the kind without the store-bought package? Traditional homemade American pudding is made from dairy (milk or cream) and thickening agents like cornstarch or egg yolks. It’s almost like the base for an ice cream! The ingredients are whisked together on the stovetop, then chilled in the refrigerator until firm. You’ll do the same thing for pumpkin pudding, adding pumpkin puree and pumpkin pie spices. Here’s what you’ll need:
Pantry: Pumpkin puree, sugar, cornstarch, pumpkin pie spice, cinnamon, turmeric, salt, vanilla extract, apple cider vinegar Dairy: 2% or whole milk, butter, heavy cream (for whipped cream) Special ingredients: Gingersnap cookies, graham crackers or pecans Other: Small glasses or bowls, for serving Time: 10 minutes for prep, 2 hours for chilling, 5 to 10 minutes for presentation
A trick for color
This pumpkin pudding looks great as is, but the color can look rather brown depending on the canned pumpkin puree you use. Want to boost the color? Add ⅛ teaspoon ground turmeric. It adds a bit of yellow color without adding anything flavor-wise.
Refrigerating makes it fully thick
You’ll simply whisk together the ingredients for the pudding over medium heat until thickened, then transfer to bowls to set in the refrigerator. It will thicken to pudding-like consistency after refrigerating for about 2 hours. Here’s what to know about this process:
Plan in advance for the refrigeration step! The hands on portion of this recipe takes only about 10 minutes. But the refrigerating takes a few hours. You may want to make this the day before you plan to serve and store in the fridge. No need to press plastic wrap or wax paper onto the surface. You can place all the glasses on a tray and cover loosely in plastic, but no need to press the wrap into the surface. (This is required with some pudding recipes so that a skin doesn’t form on top.) Refrigerating in small glasses or bowls speeds up the process. It’s easiest to chill the way you’ll serve it: it not only speeds up the process but saves time when it comes to serving.
Ways to serve pumpkin pudding
This pumpkin pudding tastes great on its own, but it’s even better topped with whipped cream and showered in crushed cookies or chopped nuts! We like it best with gingersnap cookies, but there are lots of other ideas. Here are a few ways to serve this pumpkin pudding recipe:
Homemade whipped cream (or purchased) Gingersnaps, crushed Graham crackers, crushed Pecans, chopped Walnuts, chopped Hazelnuts, chopped Candied walnuts or candied pecans
Keep in mind, this recipe makes enough for six ½ cup servings. It’s best to serve them in small glasses so that the glass looks full enough. However if you prefer, you can make it into a larger dessert as 4 servings.
Substitute for cornstarch
Don’t have cornstarch or don’t want to use it? Arrowroot powder is a popular substitute for cornstarch. It’s used for thickening sauces, both savory and sweet. Arrowroot powder should work well as a substitute for cornstarch in this pudding. Or, here are a few other substitutes for cornstarch.
More pumpkin desserts
This pumpkin pudding is one of our favorite pumpkin desserts, ideal for Thanksgiving as an alternative to pumpkin pie, or even Christmas. Here are a few more pumpkin desserts we love:
Go for our Best Pumpkin Cookies Bake up Pumpkin Bread Make Pumpkin Ice Cream Try this moist and delicious Perfect Pumpkin Cake or Perfect Pumpkin Bars Make this Incredible Pumpkin Pie, or go for Mini Pumpkin Pies Go for Pumpkin Mousse
This pumpkin pudding recipe is…
Vegetarian and gluten-free. No reviews
